Latest
Politics

Full 5th Circuit rules House proxy voting unconstitutional

The ruling applies only to Texas for now, but its reasoning could reach every law in the $1.7 trillion 2022 spending package.

The John Minor Wisdom courthouse of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit in New Orleans
Photo: Bobak Ha'Eri / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0

The full U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit has ruled that the House violated the Constitution when it counted members voting by proxy toward a quorum, and it blocked enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against the state of Texas.

The decision in Texas v. Blanche came Friday, Nov. 20, according to legal scholar Jonathan Adler, writing for the Volokh Conspiracy. The court had agreed in February to rehear the case with all of its active judges after a three-judge panel had ruled the other way, law firm Parker Poe noted at the time.

The ruling

“Members of Congress must be present for quorum purposes,” Judge Cory Wilson wrote for the majority. The Constitution’s Quorum Clause, he wrote, “does not allow proxies to be included when establishing a quorum.”

Nine judges joined the majority. Judge James Graves wrote a dissent joined by six colleagues, arguing the majority “shoehorns a much larger requirement into the Constitution” by demanding physical presence. Judge Catharina Haynes dissented separately.

What law is affected

The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act requires employers to make reasonable accommodations for pregnant workers. It passed in December 2022 as part of a roughly $1.7 trillion government funding bill, while the House still allowed proxy voting under pandemic-era rules.

The numbers explain why the case matters. The House passed the bill 225-201. Of the 431 votes cast, 226 were by proxy and only 205 in person, according to the dissent. Without the proxies, there weren’t enough members physically present for a quorum.

Who it applies to

For now, the ruling only stops federal enforcement of the pregnant workers law against Texas as a state employer, which is the only relief Texas asked for. Private employers and other states are still covered.

But the same reasoning could apply to everything else in that spending bill, including the TikTok ban on federal devices and the Electoral Count Reform Act, Adler wrote.

What’s next

The federal government can ask the Supreme Court to take the case. Adler said a petition “writes itself” and predicted the decision is unlikely to stand. Until then, the ruling is binding in the 5th Circuit, which covers Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi.

Book of News Staff

The Book of News newsroom covers breaking news, politics, business, markets, sports and culture across the United States. Every story is fact-checked against multiple reliable sources before publication.

Join the discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *